LandlordEzy
Case Study

LTB Order on Smoking Violation and Eviction

Conditional Relief and Tenant's Responsibilities

🕑 Case timeline

Application Date: Date not provided

Hearing Date: 2023-09-05

Order Issued: 2023-11-24

Termination Date: Date not provided

Eviction Deadline: Date not provided

ℹ️ Case overview

Case Number: LTB-L-046839-22
Address: 1, 223 Ontario St, St Catharines ON L2R5L2
Form Used: Form N5
Served By: Landlord
Amount Awarded: $186.00
Decision In Favor: Conditional relief granted to Tenant
Application Type: Eviction for substantial interference with reasonable enjoyment
RTA Sections: Section 69, Section 83, Section 78

👥 Parties involved

Landlord: John Janzen
Landlord Rep: J. Callender
Tenant: Melissa Carvalho, Alexander Kudelski
Tenant Rep: Self Represented
Adjudicator: Peter Nicholson
Keywords: eviction, substantial interference, reasonable enjoyment, smoking violation, conditional relief

⚖️ Decision summary

Tenant to comply with no-smoking rules within specified areas or face eviction.
Tenant to pay Landlord application costs by specified date or accrue interest.

⚠️ Dispute summary

Dispute centers on Tenant's smoking close to the building, violating lease terms.
Multiple complaints from other tenants about the smoke.

📑 Findings & determinations

Tenant's behavior interfered with another tenant's enjoyment and Landlord's rights.
Tenant given conditional relief to correct behavior to avoid eviction.

💡 Summary points

Tenant accused of smoking within prohibited distance causing substantial interference.
Landlord served two N5 notices for repeated smoking violations.
Conditional relief granted; eviction denied if Tenant complies with no-smoking order.
📄 View Official PDF

Share this case

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Instagram

🏷️ Related by keywords

eviction substantial interference reasonable enjoyment smoking violation conditional relief

Eviction Order for Non-payment of Rent

2803, 240 Wellesley St E, Toronto

Matched Keyword

LTB Order for Eviction and Payment of Rent Arrears

Case LTB-L-071895-22 Decision

Matched Keyword

Eviction Order for Non-Compliance with Termination Agreement

LTB Order Review: Montesano v Lolic

Matched Keyword

🧑‍⚖️ Same adjudicator

Peter Nicholson

Eviction Order Review Denied for Non-Payment of Rent

Review of LTB Order LTB-L-019588-22

Same Adjudicator

Eviction Order for Non-payment of Rent

Case LTB-L-017794-22

Same Adjudicator

LTB Order Review Denied for Janita Frey

Case LTB-L-000367-23-RV

Same Adjudicator

📂 Related by application type

Eviction for substantial interference with reasonable enjoyment

Eviction Order for Tenant Abi Shaju by Williams and McDaniel Property Management

Substantial Interference with Reasonable Enjoyment Leads to Eviction

Same Application Type

LTB Order - Eviction for Substantial Interference

Case LTB-L-012436-22

Same Application Type

LTB Order - Eviction for Substantial Interference

Case LTB-L-054400-22

Same Application Type